Your Academic Medicine Career: Questions to Ask Before Year-End
Promotion cycles, grant deadlines, and teaching evaluations all keep their own clocks. Here's how to check each one against your own goals.
- 11.17.2026
- Josh Hunt
- 4

Promotion cycles, teaching evaluations, and grant deadlines all run on their own clocks. Year-end is a good moment to check them against yours.
An academic medicine career pulls in several directions at once: patient care, teaching, research, committee work, and often a leadership role on top of it all. It's easy to spend a year answering whatever is due next and lose track of whether the work is adding up to the career you want.
A year-end career reflection gives you room to step back. A systematic scoping review of reflective writing in medical educationdescribes reflection as a way for physicians to review their thoughts, goals, and actions and consolidate what they've learned.
Whether you're a few years into a faculty appointment, an advanced practitioner on an academic team, or leading a department, these questions are here to help you take stock. Jot down your answers on a quiet afternoon, or bring them to your next mentor meeting and talk them through. You don't need a big decision in mind to get something useful out of it.
How do you know if your academic medicine career is on track?
Your academic medicine career is on track when your work lines up with two things: the goals you've set for yourself and the criteria your institution uses for promotion. Checking only one of them can leave you surprised at review time.
The second half is harder than it sounds. The AAMC's leadership guide for faculty affairs professionals notes that faculty members may be unaware or uncertain about promotion criteria in their department or school and need clear guidance on what their institution expects.
Questions about your promotion track
- Which promotion track am I on, and does it still match the work I'm actually doing?
- What does my department or school count toward promotion on that track?
- Where do I stand against those criteria today, and what's missing?
- Who in faculty affairs or my department can confirm the parts I'm unsure about?
Questions about your own goals
- What did I want this year to look like, and how close did it come?
- Which parts of my work (clinical, teaching, research, leadership) do I want more of, and which do I want less of?
- What am I better at now than I was a year ago?
If your two sets of answers point in different directions, that's useful to know early. A gap might call for a conversation about a different track, a shift in where your effort goes, or a clearer read on what your institution values.
How can a mentor help you check your direction?
A 2025 commentary in Academic Medicine offers a simple framework for faculty and their mentors built around three ideas: doing what you love, making your work count twice, and staying focused. The authors suggest working through each one in steps: reflect on current activities, confirm whether they fit your goals, and explore what could come next.
The framework works at any career stage, though the answers tend to shift as you move from early-career to senior faculty.
Are you doing what you love?
This question asks where your best energy is going and whether that's where you want it. The commentary's follow-up prompts include what draws your interest when you read the literature and whether you're building real expertise in that area.
Mid-career faculty in particular may find their interests have moved since they first set their direction. That's worth naming out loud, since it shapes every other answer on this list.
Are you making it count twice?
This question asks whether one piece of work can serve more than one goal. A curriculum you built could become a conference workshop and a paper, and a clinical quality project could feed both your teaching and your scholarship.
The commentary points out that promotion criteria are defined for every track, and that many schools now recognize scholarship beyond journal articles, including conference presentations, workshops, and some digital formats. Check which of those your own institution counts.
Are you staying focused?
This question works on two levels. The big-picture level asks whether you have a reasonable number of commitments or are overextended. The day-to-day level asks whether each commitment is actually getting done on time.
The commentary also frames focus as knowing when to say "yes," "no," or "not now" to a new opportunity.
How do you document your contributions before year-end?
An educator portfolio is the clearest way to capture a year of teaching and educational work. Updating it at year-end records what you did while the details are fresh and gives you something concrete to review with a mentor.
The AAMC describes the educator portfolio as a written record of your teaching strengths and educational innovations that complements your CV. It also notes that putting one together encourages reflection on your own skills and accomplishments.
Developmental and promotional portfolios
The AAMC separates two versions. A developmental portfolio tracks your activities and achievements over time and supports goal setting. A promotional portfolio summarizes your key educational achievements when you go up for advancement.
The year-end update belongs in the developmental version. Keeping it current makes the promotional version far easier to pull together when the time comes.
What to add this year
- Courses, lectures, and clinical teaching you delivered, with any learner evaluations
- Curriculum you designed or revised
- Learners you mentored or advised, and where they are now
- Educational leadership roles and committee work
- Presentations, workshops, and publications tied to your teaching
- Feedback from learners or colleagues that stuck with you
If your work leans toward research or clinical care, the same habit applies to your CV and any track-specific documentation your institution asks for.
Does your mentoring and sponsorship network match what you need now?
Your network should fit the stage you're in today, which may be different from the stage you were in when you built it. It also helps to know whether you have mentors, sponsors, or both, because they do different work.
A mentor serves as your career guide. A sponsor puts your name forward for a specific role or opportunity. The AAMC draws that same distinction in its guidance on mentoring.
Mentorship and sponsorship programs are one of the main ways institutions support faculty, according to the AAMC's guide to maximizing faculty success. If you're not sure what your institution offers, start with your faculty affairs or faculty development office.
Questions to check your network
- Who do I go to for career guidance, and when did we last meet?
- Did anyone put my name forward this year for a role, award, committee, or speaking invitation?
- Do my mentors fit my current goals, or the goals I had when we started working together?
- Is there an area (research methods, educational scholarship, leadership) that no one in my network covers?
- Who am I mentoring or sponsoring, and is that commitment still a good fit?
Which commitments advance your priorities, and which scatter your effort?
Sort this year's commitments by whether they moved you toward your own goals, your promotion criteria, or both. Anything that did neither is a candidate to wind down, hand off, or decline the next time it comes around.
This is where "Are you staying focused?" turns practical. Picture a mid-career faculty member with three committee seats, a curriculum project, and a grant resubmission. Two of those committees may count as service, yet neither connects to the educational work they want to be known for.
A quick commitment audit
- List every recurring commitment: clinical, teaching, research, committee, and leadership.
- Next to each, note which goal or promotion criterion it serves, if any.
- Mark the ones that could count twice with a small change in how you approach them.
- Circle the ones you'd drop if you could, and ask what it would take.
Yes, no, or not now
The Academic Medicine commentary offers a simple way to handle what comes next. When you say yes, be clear about the scope, timeline, and resources. When you say no, thank the person and be honest with yourself about why.
When the answer is "not now," decide when and how you'll revisit it. That keeps a good opportunity from turning into a vague obligation.
What should academic leaders ask themselves at year-end?
For chairs, division chiefs, program directors, and other academic leaders, year-end reflection comes down to one question: does the role have what it needs to deliver what you were brought in to do? A title and the real scope behind it can drift apart over a year or two.
The AAMC notes that faculty join institutions at many leadership levels, and many will have chances to take on new leadership roles along the way. That makes a clear read on your current role useful whether you plan to stay in it or grow from it.
Mandate
- What was I asked to accomplish in this role, and has that changed since I started?
- Which parts of that mandate moved forward this year, and which stalled?
Authority
- Do I have decision rights over the things I'm accountable for, such as faculty recruitment, program design, and budget?
- Where do I need sign-off that slows the work down?
Resources
- Are the budget, staff support, faculty lines, and protected time in place to meet the mandate?
- What would I ask for if I had one conversation with my dean?
Stakeholder alignment
- Where do the priorities of the dean, the department, the faculty, and the health system line up?
- Where do they differ, and who is aware of the gap?
The commentary's big-picture focus question applies at this level too. Before taking on a new initiative, ask how it fits your current role and the vision you have for the next few years. For a closer look at how senior academic opportunities are evaluated, see this overview for executives and leaders.
What next steps don't require a career move?
The most useful year-end steps are small: one conversation, one updated document, or one decision about a single commitment. A clearer picture of your career can lead to staying put, adjusting your current role, or exploring options later on your own timeline.
- Schedule a mentor meeting and bring your answers to these questions.
- Ask your chair or faculty affairs office to walk through the criteria for your promotion track.
- Update your educator portfolio and CV while this year is still fresh.
- Have one conversation about protected time, scope, or support in your current role.
- Pick one commitment to wind down, hand off, or decline.
- Put a date on the calendar to revisit your answers in six months.
If you're curious how academic opportunities compare elsewhere, these overviews for physicians and advanced practitioners cover what to weigh beyond compensation. Learning about your options doesn't commit you to anything.
Conclusion
A year-end check-in gives your academic medicine career the same attention you give a promotion packet or a grant deadline, on your own schedule. The most useful questions to carry into the new year:
- Does my work line up with both my own goals and my institution's promotion criteria?
- Am I doing what I love, making it count twice, and staying focused?
- Is my educator portfolio current?
- Do my mentors and sponsors fit where I am now?
- Which commitments move me forward, and which scatter my effort?
- For leaders: do my mandate, authority, resources, and stakeholder alignment match?
None of these questions need a perfect answer. What matters is noticing where your time and energy actually went this year, holding that up against what your institution rewards and what you want from your work, and choosing one or two small adjustments.
Some answers will confirm you're right where you want to be. Others might point to a conversation with your chair, a portfolio that needs updating, or a commitment you're ready to set down. Either way, you'll head into the new year with a clearer read on your career and a few concrete next steps.
Pick the one or two questions that stood out most and start there.
Frequently Asked Questions
What questions should healthcare providers ask themselves at the end of the year?
Start with three: What went well this year? What matters most to me now? What would help me move forward? From there, add questions specific to your work, such as promotion criteria for academic faculty or scope and support for advanced practitioners. A clear answer can lead to staying put, adjusting your current role, or exploring later.
How often should faculty update an educator portfolio?
Treat it as a working document. The AAMC describes the developmental educator portfolio as a way to track activities over time, so add entries as they happen and do a fuller review before annual evaluations or a mentor meeting.
What's the difference between a mentor and a sponsor in academic medicine?
A mentor guides your career with advice and perspective. A sponsor advocates for you for a specific role, committee, or opportunity. The AAMC treats them as distinct, so it helps to know which of the two you have.
What does "making it count twice" mean for faculty?
It means getting more than one result from the same effort. A teaching innovation, for example, might also become a conference presentation or a publication, so it serves both your teaching and your scholarship goals.
Do you need to be planning a move to do a year-end career review?
No. A year-end career reflection is useful whether you're happy where you are, considering a change, or somewhere in between. Most of the steps involve a conversation, an updated document, or a clearer list of priorities.
Sources
- Freeland DG, Verbsky J, Babbott S. Three Good Questions for Faculty and Their Mentors in Support of Academic Career Development. Academic Medicine. 2025;100(8):880–883. https://academic.oup.com/academicmedicine/article/100/8/880/8361596
- Association of American Medical Colleges. Managing Career Transitions and Succession. Leadership Guide, Faculty and Staff Vitality Group. https://www.aamc.org/learn-network/affinity-groups/faculty-staff-vitality-group/leadership-guide/managing-career-transitions-and-succession
- Bates CK. General Career Development: Maximizing the Success of Your Faculty. Association of American Medical Colleges, Leadership Guide, Faculty and Staff Vitality Group. https://www.aamc.org/learn-network/affinity-groups/faculty-staff-vitality-group/leadership-guide/maximizing-success-your-faculty
- Association of American Medical Colleges. The Educator Portfolio: A Tool for Career Development. Faculty Vitae. https://www.aamc.org/professional-development/affinity-groups/gfa/faculty-vitae/educator-portfolio-tool
- Ward WL. Mentoring. Association of American Medical Colleges, Leadership Guide, Faculty and Staff Vitality Group. https://www.aamc.org/learn-network/affinity-groups/faculty-staff-vitality-group/leadership-guide/mentoring
- Lim et al. A systematic scoping review of reflective writing in medical education. BMC Medical Education. 2023;23:12. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9830881
Other articles

Year-End Questions for Physicians and Advanced Practitioners, Even If You're Not Planning a Move
Not planning a move? These year-end questions help physicians and advanced practitioners see their progress and get clear on what comes next.

Physician Recruitment Metrics to Review Before 2027
This year's offers, hires, and departures already say a lot about next year's plan. Here are the physician recruitment metrics to review first.

Stated Culture vs. Lived Culture: Evaluating a Community, Tribal, or Rural Role
A mission statement says why a health center exists. Here's how to tell if you can build a career and a life in a rural or Tribal role.

Stated Culture vs. Lived Culture: A Dental and Allied Health Guide
What a workplace says about itself is a starting point. Here’s how to see what it’s actually like before you sign.
Get in Touch
Book a consultation with our team today
Whether you're an organization looking to fill key roles, or a professional exploring your options, our recruitment experts are here to help. Zero cost, no commitment. Completely confidential.


